GEOX · Earth intelligence
Home

Earth Witness

A photo is not the rock. This page writes down what the picture shows, asks for the tests a camera cannot do, and stops at a candidate. It does not seal a well, a prospect, or an age.

Reading organ status…

Put a ruler in the frame when you can. A coin or a hand is only a rough size. Compton’s field rule still holds: measure, then name.

What is in the picture

Pick the kind of picture. The tests below change with it. Leave it blank and the organ will guess the kind of picture, not the rock.

hand specimen outcrop core thin section fossil seismic map cross-section
Tests the camera cannot do

These remove impossible names. They do not prove one name. 10% dilute HCl: vigorous fizz is calcite, powder-only is dolomite, silence is not a carbonate. Steel is about Mohs 5.5. Grain size is Wentworth.

HCl vigorous HCl powder only HCl silent
softer than a nail softer than a coin softer than steel harder than steel
strongly magnetic weakly magnetic not magnetic
clay / silt fine sand medium sand coarse sand gravel crystals, too fine to see crystals you can see
rhombohedral cleavage sheets conchoidal fracture prismatic cubic
Which way is up

Only if you saw the beds in place. A loose specimen has no way-up.

way-up known way-up unknown
Scale in the frame

A measured ruler is calibrated. A coin (~24 mm) or a hand (~180 mm) is a hint, and the reply will still ask for a real scale.

ruler in frame coin only hand only
Display, not the earth

A bright spot is not gas. Amplitude is not a fluid. Say the display polarity and whether the axis is time or depth. Without polarity, a hard kick and a soft kick cannot be told apart.

SEG normal SEG reverse
time (ms) depth (m)
near stack far stack
Shape is not an age

The picture can support a look-alike. An age needs a taxon and a public range (Paleobiology Database), then a person. Cuttings can be caved from higher up the hole.

scale bar is in the photo
from an outcrop from core from cuttings
Basin — context only

Naming Sabah or the Malay Basin does not make the guess stronger.

unknown Sabah Malay Sarawak other
What you want from the look
just look teaching lithology facies structure

The upload stays in memory for this reply. Strike and dip are not read off a photograph — measure those with a compass.

What this page will not do

Field habit from Compton, Geology in the Field: describe the outcrop before you interpret it, and compare grain size with a real scale. Wentworth cuts used here: clay/silt under 0.0625 mm, fine sand to 0.25, medium to 0.5, coarse to 2, gravel above that.

Qualified candidate — not an interpretation of record